I completely understand your stress...
I’m a 48 y.o. male living near Philly. I had a 2.3 cm AN (snuggled up against my brainstem) diagnosed in June 2014. I had almost no hearing loss in my AN ear. I had faint tinnitus in the AN ear, very slight balance issues, some faint facial numbness on the AN side of my mouth. I would not have acted on my symptoms, but luckily, my AN was an incidental finding in a CAT scan and then confirmed by contrasted MRI.
After a bit of freaking out (actually quite a bit, straightened out by my wife who dealt with the diagnosis better than I), we met and consulted with Penn (Bigelow/Lee - strongly recommended retrosig), Jefferson (Wilcox/Evans/Andrews - willing to watch and wait, surgery (recommended retrosig), or radio (Andrews speciality)) and Hopkins (Francis/Tamargo - strong retrosig recommendation). I also had phone consults with House (Wilkinson/Schwarz - recommended surgery, and translab over retrosig).
It then took me a month to make my decision - translab surgery at House/St Vincents. A difficult decision, due to the conflicting recommendations of the experts, and mostly anecdotal info about the outcomes of my options. I chose House over some great local/east-coast options, because as far as _I_ could establish, they had more extensive and current AN surgery experience. And almost more importantly… my “gut feeling”, following all of the surgeon consults, had me favoring House.
I'm now 11 weeks out from surgery and doing awesome! My AN was completely removed, I had no complications, and I was back about most all activities 4 weeks post surgery. E.g., driving, back to work, daily exercise, etc. My thanks, and great result in my opinion, go to my fantastic House surgeons, Dr.s Slattery and Schwarz, as well as Dr Stephan and the St Vincents staff.
I hope that your continued research and consults with experienced treatment teams soon pays off for you, with a decision that YOU control and are at peace with, and ultimately results in your AN experience being another small bump in the road of life. Take care!