I know my doctor recommended some things, but I've found by trial and error what works best for me.
I use gel at night - I think I've tried them all. I like the Refresh PM the best. I don't often use drops during the day, but if I do, it's usually Theratears. I carry Celluvisc with me too, some days it just feels better with something a little thicker in there, but I'd have to say, if I need to use the thicker stuff, it's less than once a month. It's usually not due to a real lack of moisture, but because something got in my eye - dust or something - and it felt irritated.
I've never used the plastic wrap or eye bubble, except while in the ICU right after surgery. I tried the stick on eye bubble for night time, but it drove me crazy - so it probably stayed on about 10 minutes before I ditched it!
I agree with Kay though, it does sound like a bit of overkill, but maybe there's a good reason your doctor suggests doing all of that. I was a Brackmann 6/6 for a little while and then a 5/5 for about a year and a half and I still didn't do as much as you're doing. I guess it's better to do too much in this case than too little.I had my tear ducts cauterized at about 2 months post op and it was after that procedure that I was able to do away with the daytime drops for the most part.
Good luck with the eye weight - I'm sure that will cut down on the amount of "stuff" you have to do to your eye!
Lori