Jill Marie and I have been going through this investigation at the same time - I am surprised and very pleased with how much relief (and not just for my eye) I am getting with the soft contact lens - mine are 1-Day Acuvue TrueEye.
When I got my first prescription for glasses, I decided to check into scleral lens, as my right eye has produced almost no tears since my AN surgery 26 years ago. So many of us know the unending pain that can produce - there were days when I could have put any entire tube of goop in my eye every hour and get still get no relief.
I have been wearing my soft lens for two weeks now and have been amazed at the results - there have been many, many days when I put a very small amount of goop in my eye in the morning and do nothing more the rest of the day until I take the lens out to go to sleep. Other days, I've needed a very small mid-day and then I'm good to go.
I've been basically pain free since I've started wearing the lens. A completely unexpected bonus happened, however. With the return of my AN and a very stressful job, the symptoms have reappeared and along with them, what I thought was extreme fatigue. Since wearing the lenses, though, my fatigue symptoms have completely disappeared. I feel refreshed all day long and find that my concentration levels at work have returned to where they were two years ago before my beast reared its head again. I have no clue why this is happening - maybe taking one unrelenting symptom away may have relieved something in my overtaxed brain - but I honestly feel as if I am getting a big part of my life back.
If you have dry eye, I strongly recommend looking into the new lens. I believe that Jill Marie is using another brand, so there are several options. Not all eye docs appear to be aware that these lens are options for us, though. I got lucky and went to a PROSE center and had a doctor very aware of dry eye options.