Since you say you're close to getting full eye closure and don't want to spend the money for a scleral lens you might want to try the lens I use now after using the scleral lens, it's the Acuvue Oasys with HydraLuxe daily lens. The lens doesn't need to be fitted, put it in your eye in the morning and throw it out at night, no cleaning or soaking the lens. Cost $1 a day. What you are doing now obviously doesn't work, either your using drops and or ointment that doesn't agree with your eye or your not using enough of them. When your eye that doesn't close isn't doing well it overworks your other eye and that is why you're having problems with it now. Everyone is different so keep trying tell you find what works. I've had severe dry eye for 24 years now and the lens I use now is the only thing that kept me from wanting my eye removed because of the pain, no problem now. Good Luck, Jill