I did finish Blindness ... didn't like the way it was written but it did hold a message about human nature and how different people
would react in time of crisis ... some help others while some are all about taking care of themselves ...
Soundy
When the movie "Blindness" came out the National Federation of the Blind, an organization which I am a member of, protested the movie. I was part of a protest here in New York. Basically we felt that it was supporting stereotypes of what it's like to be blind that were just ridiculous. The movie actually turned out to be a bomb in theaters. That's the funny thing about protesting a movie. Sometimes you can have the opposite effect. I think more people actually went to see it because they wanted to know what all the controversy was about. As a person affected by blindness, I see how people are repelled by those of us who are blind. The NFB strives to show blindness for what it is and that's not what was portrayed in that film. I've found a sort of parallel in my disability and the AN in my head. People don't seem to get either concept too well. I have low vision. I am a blind person. Yes I have some vision. I have vision that is so low that I AM A BLIND PERSON! Being blind isn't just "no sight at all" and that's the definition that most people think about.
I would be very upset to know that some teacher is using this book in a school to teach 7th and 8th graders unless it was a leasson on disabilities and part of the class consisted of various blind people visiting the class and to teach what blindness really is about. By the way if any teachers in the US are reading this and would like to have a school visit from blind people I may be able to put you in touch with people who can make that happen.
Glen
Our teachers after several of us read it and reported our opinions rejected it for the reading list …
The story could have used any disability or major crisis to put these people at a disadvantage and still shown the message that in a crisis some people will rise to the top as people who care and others will take advantage of others and make sure that their needs are met no matter what …we are seeing this locally right now with all the tornado victims and the way people have reacted …
one gas station owner that still had power letting people with proof of living in the area to get 10 gallons and he paying for it until his tanks were dry while others were charge with gouging when they upped the price on the then limited supply they had to $5 - $6 a gallon , well over the $3.60 or so it was running …
The best thing about the small school my girls attend is that we are very accepting and conscientious to people with any kind of disability … right now we have one boys that was born with an incomplete brain … his parents live out of district but bring him to our school because he gets a lot of love and attention from teachers , students and volunteers … anything he learns is a celebration … when he came to us he was anti social and at 6 not walking even though doctors thought he should be able to … he grunted and cried most of the time …he now walks after wearing most of us out as it took two people to hold his hands and walk with him … now he is is a walking machine and loves walking the halls … he will never talk but now signs to us or communicates using pictures we have taking of different places and people at school … he can’t swallow and has a tube in his chest that goes to his stomach … he can tell us he is hungry and can now get a snack of liquid nourishment between his regular feedings … and now at 9 he is beginning potty training … I am so glad we have him … not only for the good he has received but for the good he has done for our kids from Kindergarten through 8th grade …. It is hard to explain it but he belongs to all of us …
We also have a boy who is autisitc … he is an 8th grader and will move to the high school which scares me …he is also from out of our district … we have another 8th grader who as a 6th grader begin his self appointed job of helpmate to his boy and his aide … he came to our school in the 5th grade … he was not toilet trained at school even though he was at home …and he would read but wouldn’t write … he screamed a lot and his aide had a hard time with him … at the school he had been at , when he acted out he was restrained … at the start of the 6th grade the other boy saw the aide crying and just started helping … he potty trained him … I know his sounds odd , but he would take him in the bathroom and show him how to pee in the toilet …he would drop a square of TP in it and sink it … he thought this was funny and had to try …result is he was trained at school in about 6 months … his friend didn’t even have to try to work on BM training …once he got down the peeing in the school bathrooms he decided on his own that the other could be done there too … the old school had him since kindergarten and didn’t figure out how to work with him and just strapped him to a Gerry chair and let him sit looking out windows for a big part o the day …
he hates math and refuses to do anything other than adding … but makes straight As in history … we set up a lab to teach life skills (shopping , folding clothes , simple cooking etc) …he will spot any of the items that are out of place in the store area and puts things in order all lined up neatly… at the talent show with his helping shadow standing beside him he sang in front of a crowd of about 600 people … a long way from the boy who was scared if more that a dozen people were near him …I hope that the boy that shadows him and has become a very important part of his life can be with him part of the time at the high school … I fear he ill once again become lost in the shuffle … his aide applied for and was given the job of continuing on with him …at least he will have her and not be passed off on someone else
Sorry to go on … I am just proud that our school has a reputation as where to take your child if they need something extra … we have some parents that complain about what they term the added trouble and distraction … but the kids at school get such a valuable lesson from these special needs kids …it makes them better people to have the exposure … I have thought at times that they are angels sent to teach along with being children there to learn …
The book aside from not being written very well ( in my opinion) just didn’t have much to offer to 7th and 8th grade readers ( again my opinion) …