Author Topic: Newly Diagnosed - Incidental Finding and Healthy!  (Read 318 times)

stayingpositive31

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 2
Newly Diagnosed - Incidental Finding and Healthy!
« on: November 10, 2026, 03:57:01 PM »
Hi Everyone!

Just looking for thoughts and hopefully some similar situations. Would also love to know where folks were treated (surgical or radiation) and how you decided? How many opinions did you get!? Anyone recent with UNC or Vanderbilt?

I'm a 35 year old female who was just diagnosed last week with a 2.9cm acoustic neuroma (right side). This was an entirely incidental finding so you can imagine the shock factor (had an MRI and CT after I bumped my head in a very lame/minor bike accidents). I have my ENT appointment tomorrow with my list of ~30 questions and have since sequestered myself from the hell hole that is Googling this thing.

I have very minimal symptoms, no headaches, fog, dizziness or gait changes. My hearing was actually tested in March of 2026 because I noticed a slight difference in my right ear vs. left. It came back with a slight deficit comparatively but still well within normal ranges. I feel like I hear really well! Ironically, right after the MRI I noticed some minor lip and tongue numbness but it's pretty faint.

The total measurements are 1.7cm x 2.9cm x 1.9cm. My results say I am mildly expanding into my right internal auditory canal but it's not involved in the cochlea or vestibule. I DO have a bit of brainstem compression noted but no swelling or fluid issues currently.

Was anyone in the same boat? What was your approach? Part of me is like get this bad boy out of here TOMORROW, part of me is like wow I have really no issues, if radiation is even on the table should I consider it?

I am a very active biker and power lifter and in good shape.

Mark F.

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 90
Re: Newly Diagnosed - Incidental Finding and Healthy!
« Reply #1 on: November 11, 2026, 08:38:39 PM »
To answer a few of your questions.  I am not in your area, I live in Western Maryland, I had opinions from John's Hopkins, and Hershey Medical Center.  They are two of the best facilities around me, and in my opinion some of the best in the country.  At first both places recommended watch and wait, but when it was constantly growing every time I went back, and symptoms kept multiplying, Hopkins recommended surgery, Hershey recommended radiation.  My choice was surgery at Hopkins.  I do not regret my choice one bit, I am far better off now (Just 18 months post op) than I was before surgery.   But others on here have had just as much success with radiation.  All options should be considered, but in the end choose the one you are most comfortable with.  Mine was very symptomatic as the majority of it was in the ear canal and pressing on multiple other nerves. Yours being mostly out of the canal is probably why you are not experiencing many symptoms at the moment.  The pressing on the brain stem that you mention may speed up your doctors recommendation, but usually this is a long drawn out process.  I know it's easy to say don't worry, but you will find out that many people have positive outcomes.   Also, if you do experience hearing loss eventually, that real isn't as bad as you think.  I am now single side deaf, and before surgery I really thought that hearing preservation was a top priority,  but if I would have known that I could feel this much better but I would have to give up my left ear, I would have taken that choice years ago.  You really do learn to adapt to single side hearing loss quite well.

stayingpositive31

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 2
Re: Newly Diagnosed - Incidental Finding and Healthy!
« Reply #2 on: November 12, 2026, 09:09:38 AM »
THANK YOU so much for the reply and positivity! I am feeling really lucky and grateful we found this tumor and there's a ton of great programs across the country that can support me. I am in WNC and would prefer to stay within driving distance for treatment. I had my first appointment with an ENT yesterday and he was wonderful, answered all my questions thoroughly and spent about an hour with me. He's done 50 AN surgeries and I appreciated his transparency on the hearing loss. For me, being young, he steered me away from radiation as results beyond 10 years are not widely known right now. He weighed translab and retrosig and his opinion was due to my tumor size the odds of having what I'll call "usable hearing" are very low regardless of approach (even radiation long term) so although translab is guaranteed SSD, he felt confident in that approach. My understanding is translab gives them the best view to my facial nerve so I figure if my destiny is SSD regardless of method, let's preserve everything else. He also felt good about saving the hearing nerve so a cochlear impact could be in my future. He said CROS would also be helpful to start.

My only stopping point right now is this ENT is new to our area, operates at a small regional hospital, and while he has done a few surgeries with the local neuro team, they have not done an AN together. He has operated at and with teams at Emory and UNC though. Seems like experience and experience as a TEAM, is equally important. I will meet the neurosurgeon he's teamed up with next week so probably will pressure test the thoughts around teamwork and the regionality of the hospital.

Appreciate your positivity around SSD, I am feeling similar!



donjehle

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 558
Re: Newly Diagnosed - Incidental Finding and Healthy!
« Reply #3 on: November 13, 2026, 10:18:38 AM »
Welcome, stayingpositive31, to the ANA Forums!

I know what you mean about wanting to get the bad boy out TOMORROW!  That was my plea to my neurosurgeon at Emory.  Let's not wait!  Let's remove this right now!  But he didn't give in to my begging.

My situation is totally different than yours, and my acoustic neuroma was much, much smaller than yours.  And my neurosurgeon put me on the Wait and Watch protocol.  That was five years ago this month, and I'm still watching and waiting.  My tumor has not grown at all.  So, the doctor was correct in his assessment for my situation even though I have lost most of my hearing in my left ear and had terrible bouts of dizziness and fell several times as a result of my tiny, little tumor.

But this is the counsel that I would give you in your situation, for whatever it's worth:

First of all, please realize that surgeons are almost always going to recommend surgery and will speak against radiation.  And the surgeon is usually going to tell you how the approach they use is the best.  If you speak to a doctor who specializes radiation treatment, he will tell you how radiation is superior to surgery (at least much of the time).  And he will say how the radiation method he uses is much better than the other radiation options out there.  That's just the nature of the beast; everyone thinks their way is the best.

Secondly, while I understand your desire to have treatment done close to your home (and there are many valid reasons for that), I want to encourage you to consider the best treatment options available no matter where they are across the country.  And here is my reasoning -- you are young, and this decision you make is one you will have to deal with the rest of your life.  If you make a poor choice, and the surgeon is not very skilled, there could be severe consequences for the rest of your life.  On these forums are sad stories of people whose lives were marred by horrible surgical consequences.  I know you are trying to stay positive, and I really do not mean keep you from being positive.  I WANT you to be positive.  But there are ANA members whose faces are partially paralyzed sometimes at no fault of the surgeon, but sometimes because the surgeon was not as skilled as he should have been and facial nerves were cut where they should not have been. They drool out of one side of their mouth, and they can't help it.  Some patients can't control their eyelids.  I feel so sorry for them.

So, while I want you to stay positive, I also want you to realize that there can be very serious consequences that you might have to suffer with for the next 60 years of your life.  And, to me anyway, it means that I would consider a specialist in Minnesota or Florida or California or anywhere in the country who has done thousands of acoustic neuroma treatments rather than one who is close by who has only done 50. It is your brain they are dealing with, after all, and the convenience of a close location, in my book, is not as important as having the best treatment available.

So, my recommendation to you is to check out as many options, both surgery and radiation, all across the country as you can.  Speak to specialists who do different approaches and hear why they think their way is the best for your situation.  And then make your decision, not based on location, but based on the confidence you have in the person you spoke to and in the information they shared with you.  Many specialists will not charge you for a consultation over Zoom. 

When I had a free consult with the Mayo Clinic, for instance, they had one of the top acoustic neuroma neurosurgeons (who had done thousands of vestibular schwannoma surgeries) ALONG WITH one of the nation's top radiation specialists (who wrote articles in the New England Journal of Medicine on vestibular schwannoma treatment).  When my consult was completed with both of them together, I had a balanced perspective between surgery or radiation treatment.  They both recommended the Wait and Watch Approach for my situation as did my neurosurgeon at Emory in Atlanta.  But, if they had recommended surgery (or radiation) at the Mayo Clinic, I would not have hesitated a moment to buy a ticket and fly there for treatment (even though I live in Georgia, and nowhere near Minnesota).

So, I truly want to stay positive with you, but I believe your odds of having a great result is much better if you explore as many options as you feel comfortable doing.  Don't simply go with someone who is close or someone who seems nice.  Try to find the very best vestibular schwannoma specialist you can find -- the one you have the most confidence in.  And nobody can make that decision for you except you because, after all, it is YOUR brain they will be touching.

That's my two cents, stayingpositive31.  I wish you the very best in your acoustic neuroma journey!
donjehle
Burning Tongue, Loss of Hearing & Balance, and Tinnitus led to MRI. Very small AN found on 11/23/2021
While watching and waiting, lost significant hearing. WRS now at 12% (down from 100%). Was fitted with CROS system on 3/7/22.  Stable MRI on 7/29/22
No treatment yet.